A Canary Island. A thousand ways to enjoy it.Your island guide · In English
fuerteventuratodo.Island news & beach guides
← All island news

Supreme Court upholds €303,410 accounting liability for former La Oliva treasurer

Spain’s Supreme Court has upheld José Hilarión Cabrera’s liability for a shortfall in La Oliva’s accounts, despite his later acquittal in a criminal trial.

Spain’s Supreme Court has upheld an order requiring La Oliva’s former municipal treasurer, José Hilarión Cabrera, to repay €303,410.30 over a shortfall in the Fuerteventura council’s accounts, despite his later acquittal in a criminal trial.

In a judgment dated 28 October 2026, the court dismissed Cabrera’s application for an extraordinary review of the Court of Auditors’ decisions. It found no contradiction between the accounting liability and the criminal verdict, in which a jury considered it proven that he had not appropriated municipal money.

The Court of Auditors first ordered Cabrera to repay the sum, plus interest accrued since the events, on 21 July 2022. Its judicial chamber upheld that decision on 11 July 2023, except in relation to costs.

Why the acquittal did not overturn liability

On 7 November 2025, the Provincial Court of Las Palmas acquitted Cabrera following a jury verdict that the council’s accounting was erratic and that he had not appropriated any money.

The Supreme Court said the two proceedings addressed different questions. Cabrera had not been tried for embezzlement before the Court of Auditors, but for an accounting shortfall: an unjustified debit balance or a lack of cash or supporting records in an account involving public funds.

The court said criminal embezzlement requires intent, whereas accounting liability for a shortfall can also arise from serious fault or negligence. It therefore found that the jury’s conclusion that Cabrera had not taken the money did not conflict with the earlier decision.

The Supreme Court also said the jury’s description of the council’s accounting as erratic did not absolve Cabrera of responsibility. It noted that the Court of Auditors had found that he helped prepare the accounts, recording income and expenditure, and had responsibility for safeguarding funds as treasurer.

The shortfall and the review

The Court of Auditors calculated that, after adjustments to the account known as “Caja 1. Corporación”, there should have been €313,579.06 in the treasury when the council safe was opened in April 2017. Cash found in the safe amounted to €10,168.76, leaving a shortfall of €303,410.30.

The accounting court found a causal link between what it considered the treasurer’s seriously negligent conduct and the loss to municipal funds. It also concluded that the possibility of other people having a key to the safe did not relieve him of his responsibilities.

Cabrera sought a review in February 2026, arguing that decisive new documents had emerged after the accounting judgments. These included his criminal acquittal, two cash counts, two 2019 reports by a municipal auditor and witness and expert evidence from the criminal trial.

The Supreme Court said a later judgment could not be treated as a decisive new document for reviewing an earlier one because it did not exist when the first decision was made. It also found that the witness and expert statements were not separate documents independent of the judgment that recorded them.

The court did not consider the 2019 auditor’s reports decisive: one concerned a different financial year and the other a different cash account. It said it had found no major errors or omissions in the accounts that would exempt Cabrera from accounting liability.